Every Maika Monroe Horror Movie, Ranked (Including Longlegs)

After her first role in the 2012 drama At Any Price, Maika Monroe has been acting steadily and has become known for her memorable and riveting horror characters. Before her breakout part in It Follows in 2014, she appeared in The Bling Ring in a minor capacity as Beach Girl and Mandy Chambers in the 2013 adaptation of the Joyce Maynard novel Labor Day written and directed by Jason Reitman. While Monroe has explored other genres, from science-fiction like The 5th Wave to the crime film Brothers by Blood, her horror performances stand out the most.

Monroe has starred in movies that are as quirky and unique as they are unsettling, from a psychological thriller from director Chloe Okuno to a playful and strangely delightful horror comedy. Since none of these films are traditional slashers, this proves her ability to stand out among other actors who are staples of the genre. Her most recent role in Longlegs also proves that her acting range has no limit, making her one of the most versatile Scream Queens of modern times.

7 Tau (2018)

Maika Monroe as Julia

Tau is different from Monroe’s other projects, and she played Julia, a young adult who Alex (Ed Skrein) kidnaps from a club to perform an artificial intelligence experiment on her. Julia and a drone named Tau (Gary Oldman) develop an important relationship, as Tau wants to help free Julia. She decides to trust him and their interactions are compelling. While the story is frightening, Tau doesn’t stand out from other movies about AI or from the best thrillers released in 2018.

While Tau could be a clever character study, it’s a bit lackluster, and it didn’t prove very popular, only earning a 25% rating on the Rotten Tomato Tomatometer. However, Monroe played the demanding role of Julia with ease, and when compared to her other horror performances, the actor’s talents are just as evident. She captures the character’s fear and also her determination that she will be able to survive and makes the film more watchable than it might be otherwise.

6 The Guest (2014)

Maika Monroe as Anna Peterson

The Guest

The Guest is a 2014 Thriller featuring Dan Stevens, Leland Orser, and Maika Monroe. Written by Simon Barrett and directed by Adam Wingard, the film sees a soldier show up at the door of a couple grieving the loss of their military son, offering to help in any way he can. The couple soon finds out he may not be who he claims.

Director

Adam Wingard

Release Date

September 17, 2014

Writers

Adam Wingard

Cast

Lance Reddick , Dan Stevens

Runtime

100minutes

Budget

$5 million

Expand

Monroe played Anna Peterson in The Guest, a character who is crucial to the film’s plot twist about David’s identity. When David Collins (Dan Stevens) comes home after fighting in Afghanistan and tells the Peterson family that he is their late son Caleb’s best friend, Anna can tell that he’s lying. Monroe delivers a typically strong performance, particularly in the scene where her character calls the base David left and finds out he passed away, which convinces her that something sinister is happening.

Anna is a key player in every major scene, including when Major Richard Carver (Lance Reddick) shares that David was experimented on to become a trained killer. With a 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, The Guest is one of Monroe’s most acclaimed horror movies, and the actor crafted an excellent character who listens to her gut and investigates so she can attempt to save herself and her family. However, although her turn was well-received, this isn’t one of the characters that she is most known for playing.

Related

15 Best Horror Movies About Nuns

Horror movies often use religion as a jumping-off point for their stories, and using Nuns as part of these sinister narratives can be quite scary.

5 Villains (2019)

Maika Monroe as Jules

Villains (2019)

Villains is a dark comedy thriller directed by Dan Berk and Robert Olsen. The film stars Bill Skarsgård and Maika Monroe as a pair of amateur criminals who break into a suburban home, only to discover a disturbing secret held by the homeowners, played by Jeffrey Donovan and Kyra Sedgwick. This encounter leads to a tense and twisted face-off with chilling consequences.

Director

Dan Berk , Robert Olsen

Release Date

September 20, 2019

Writers

Dan Berk , Robert Olsen

Cast

Bill Skarsgard , Maika Monroe , Blake Baumgartner , Jeffrey Donovan , Kyra Sedgwick , Noah Robbins , Nikolas Kontomanolis , Danny Johnson

Runtime

90 Minutes

Expand

Bill Skarsgard’s best movie roles include his turn as Mickey in Villains, and Monroe played his love interest and partner in crime, Jules. This is a different type of character than who Monroe typically plays, as instead of a final girl trying to find out the truth or an innocent person who finds themselves facing danger, Jules is the one committing crimes. While robbing a house in Florida, the couple is captured by George (Jeffrey Donovan) and Gloria (Kyra Sedgwick), who stole a girl who they refer to as Sweetiepie (Blake Baumgartner).

The twist that the robbers are the ones in trouble is a clever one, and Monroe stands out once again, giving a powerful performance and never looking afraid once. The fact that Villains is a horror comedy makes it one of Monroe’s more riveting films, as she doesn’t usually appear in humorous stories. Similar to how Mickey is a memorable horror role for Skarsgard, Jules proves that Monroe is a versatile actor who can appear in different genres.

4 Greta (2018)

Maika Monroe as Erica Penn

Greta

Director

Neil Jordan

Release Date

February 28, 2019

Writers

Ray Wright , Neil Jordan

Cast

Colm Feore , Raven Dauda , Thaddeus Daniels , Parker Sawyers , Zawe Ashton , Jessica Preddy , Jane Perry , Jeff Hiller , Rosa Escoda , Maika Monroe , Isabelle Huppert , Chloe Grace Moretz , Arthur Lee

Runtime

98 minutes

See also  Watch Out Blumhouse, A New Horror Movie Powerhouse Is Emerging In 2024

Expand

Monroe played Erica Penn, Frances McCullen’s (Chloë Grace Moretz) best friend, in the thriller Greta, who helps her win against the villain Greta Hideg (Isabelle Huppert). Erica lives with Frances and comes up with a clever plan to foil Greta, who follows a pattern of finding new people to spy on, obsess over, and eventually kill. At the end of the movie, Monroe’s character is at the heart of a smart and compelling twist, posing as someone else on the subway and then revealing her identity to Greta.

When the friends put Greta’s body into a chest, Monroe’s confident performance emphasizes the terror of what they have been through. Although Greta focuses on Chloë Grace Moretz’s character, both she and Monroe were praised as young adults in a life-threatening scenario. The film is one of Monroe’s more gripping horror projects because sometimes, the best friend character can be forgettable and fade into the background. That isn’t the case here, as she ensures that she is memorable, capturing how Erica is a loyal friend determined to fight back.

3 Watcher (2022)

Maika Monroe as Julia

Monroe carries all of Watcher as Julia, the main character who is new to Bucharest and realizes that she is being stalked. While her husband Francis (Karl Glusman) is busy at work, former actress Julia is bored at home, and she notices a man named Daniel Weber (Burn Gorman) looking at her from across the street. While Monroe is riveting throughout the entire runtime, she does her best work in the final scene when Daniel kills her neighbor Irina (Mădălina Anea) and she is able to save herself.

Maika Monroe’s performance in Watcher is one reason why the well-received film has an 87% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and the movie wouldn’t work as well without her powerful acting. With a less talented actor, Watcher might feel dull, as Julia spends her time walking around her new city and wondering if she really does have a stalker or if she’s afraid for no reason. However, the movie’s slow pace works, allowing Monroe to dig deep into her character. Watcher is about feeling lonely in a new place and searching for contentment, and Julia is a memorable character because she doesn’t give up.

2 Longlegs (2024)

Maika Monroe as Lee Harker

Longlegs

Longlegs is a horror thriller film by writer-director Osgood Perkins. When FBI agent Lee Harker is assigned to a serial killer cold case, their investigation leads them down a rabbit hole riddled with disturbing discoveries and the occult at the center of it all. When the trail of evidence reveals a personal connection, it becomes a race against time to prevent another murder.

Director

Oz Perkins

Release Date

July 12, 2024

Studio(s)

C2 Motion Picture Group , Saturn Films

Distributor(s)

Neon

Writers

Oz Perkins

Cast

Maika Monroe , Nicholas Cage , Alicia Witt , Blair Underwood

Runtime

101 Minutes

Expand

Even though Nicolas Cage plays the titular villain in Longlegs and gives a chilling performance every time he shows up on the screen, the film is completely driven by Maika Monroe. The actress does an incredible job of embodying her detective character and the trance-like state her character unknowingly stays in almost throughout the film. Unlike most of her other horror roles, in which Monroe gets to portray a gamut of emotions through her characters, in Longlegs, she is required to maintain a constant sense of unease and detachment from the world around her.

Despite having a limited range of emotions to play with, Monroe adds many a layer to her character with her acting forte. In many ways, she seems reminiscent of The Silence of the Lambs‘ Clarice Starling as she sets out to unravel the truth behind a series of murders. The closer she gets to finding the truth about the killer, the more she learns how the murders connect to her own past. Owing to its relatively niche appeal and slow-burn approach, Longlegs arguably does not rank as high as It Follows. It is still undoubtedly one of the best films Maika Monroe has starred in.

1 It Follows (2014)

Maika Monroe as Jay Height

It Follows

It Follows is a horror-thriller film released in 2014 and follows a college student named Jay who is terrorized by a specter of a woman that follows her everywhere she goes. When Jay has sex with her new boyfriend, he ties her up and reveals that this mysterious woman will now haunt her until she passes it on to another or is killed by her. Now haunted by a woman that only she and those once afflicted by her can see, Jay will attempt to survive and find away to break the curse.

Director

David Robert Mitchell

Release Date

March 27, 2015

Studio(s)

The Weinstein Company

Distributor(s)

The Weinstein Company

Writers

David Robert Mitchell

Cast

Olivia Luccardi , Jake Weary , Keir Gilchrist , Daniel Zovatto , Maika Monroe , Lili Sepe

Runtime

100minutes

Budget

$1.3 million

Expand

Monroe’s most acclaimed horror performance is Jay Height in the popular film It Follows, which has a 95% Rotten Tomatoes rating and is acclaimed for its supernatural story. As a teenager who sleeps with her boyfriend Hugh (Jake Weary) and finds out that he transferred to her an entity that changes forms, the actor proved her staying power in the horror genre. Since much of the movie involves Jay being followed by this figure, who looks different each time, Monroe’s acting abilities stand out even more, as she is able to infuse her character with necessary fear.

Maika Monroe‘s It Follows performance is her strongest and most notable, and while the story might feel corny or hard to believe if someone else had starred in the film, she has a relatable and believable quality that makes the movie feel more realistic. While each role that she plays is memorable, there is something special about Jay that showed the actor’s star power and made it easy to become interested in her future projects.